To secure the roof of your home, we don’t leave any stone unturned, literally.
But sometimes, the most important things get missed out in terms of product choice and quality factors. As long as you’ve managed to land over here, we’re sure that you’re concerned enough to acquire the best roof underlayment for your home.
we’ve analyzed 174 of the products available in the market, and hand-picked the top 10 of them. Once done, we’ve handed the list over our in house product analysts to figure out the pros and cons of them.
Finally, the article you are up to right now is the collection of the top 10 best roof underlayment reviews of 2019. Keep reading until you find the right one for you.
Let’s start off-
Best Roof Underlayment 2019 – Comparison Table
Our Team Researched Roof Underlayment On The Market September 2019.
ArmorLay 25 Synthetic Roof Underlayment – Top Rated Roof Underlayment
It’s only fair that we give you the top-rated roof underlayment at the very beginning. It’s usually how things begin, right?
When it comes to the overall features of the ArmorLay 25, we must first look at its weight distribution.
If a thousand square roll weighs less than 25-pounds, then it’s usually an indicator that the product stacks up really well with the pricey brands in the market. Also, the overall strength of the material is pretty robust as well.
Other than that, the fabric texture does deserve a kudos. It’s really versatile in the sense that you can easily place your footing in the slopes of your roof. Not only that, but it also features a 60-day UV ray exposure, which is an added bonus.
Overall, for a waterproof roof underlayment, it certainly gets all the basics right. It doesn’t just get them right, it does so with efficiency. You won’t really find a better option than this.
Tyvek Protec 120 – Best Roof Underlayment for Asphalt Shingles
If you’re looking for the best roof underlayment for asphalt shingles, then the Tyvek Protec 120 should be on your wishlist. Despite its wide range of compatibility, it still does offer a bit more whenever you’re dealing with asphalt shingles.
For starters, the textured underlayment isn’t just weatherproof. As a matter of fact, the texture adds added overall functionality for safe operation during construction. And that’s a convenient feature in itself.
Other than the solid compatibility and usability, you’re getting a really solid roof underlayment. We think it’s just the right choice for homeowners and professionals alike.
ORGILL ROOFING FELT 30RF – Best Roofing Underlayment for Older Homes
The makers at ORGILL ROOFING FELT have a few solid options for the homeowners out there. And one of them is their 30RF standard roofing felt, which has a few distinct features up its sleeve.
For starters, it’s a bit on the thicker side. And that’s actually better when you’re dealing with old roofing, as it adds an extra layer of weather-proofing overall. This distinct feature along with its solid safety features makes it the best roofing underlayment for older homes.
Although it’s not as functional as some of the other prominent options out there, the overall feature set is still satisfactory. Thanks to its solid durability and better usability against slopes, it’s a pretty solid option overall.
Grace Ice & Water Shield – Best Waterproof Roofing Underlayment
There are very few options out there which have such a solid material impervious to water damage like the Grace Ice and Water Shield. It doesn’t just boast about its robust material of choice. As a matter of fact, it’s got a really good mix of features, including a strong resistance against water leakage.
Strong water shielding is one of its strong suits. The self-containing membrane isn’t just a decent sealant. In fact, the industrial-grade materials are capable of resisting foreign growth, which does deserve some attention as well.
These features certainly add extra value to the overall functionality aspect. It also makes the Grace and Ice Water Shield one of the best options for the best waterproof roofing underlayment.
Other than that, this strong underlayment does feature a decent textured surface, which offers better overall safety than some of the other brands out there. So, other than someone who has a flat roof, we believe it is a worthy option for you.
Synthetic Roll – Best Synthetic Roof Underlayment
Although synthetic roof underlayment options are a bit on the higher side, many prefer these options because of the added safety and usability features.
With that in mind, we present to you one of the best options for the best synthetic roof underlayment. Although the pricing is a bit steep, we do believe it is the perfect match for the folks looking for a tough underlayment choice.
Other than the 100% recyclable material, it features both an anti-skid bottom coating and no-slip foot traction feature. Both of them offer a safe working environment for professionals. Also, the resistance against any foreign growth is commendable as well.
Overall, if you don’t mind less breathability, then this roofing underlayment can be a very solid choice for your needs.
Firestone Rubberguard™ 60 Mil Epdm – Best Underlayment for EPDM Roofing
EPDM roofing, though a fairly new feature in existence, is very popular among homeowners and professionals. And if you’re in the market for the best roof underlayment, then the Firestone Rubberguard can be a very suitable option.
Despite its fairly thick material, it’s very tough and durable. And if you’re dealing with sloped surfaces, then the ease of use is very satisfactory with the Firestone. Overall, if you pair the easy handling and solid material of choice, then you have a real contender for the best underlayment for EPDM roofing at hand.
All in all, if you’re a DIY user and don’t really have any problems regarding the thickness distribution, then you can certainly go for this option.
ARMA Foil, Radiant Barrier, High Strength – Best Residential Roofing Underlayment
When it comes to industrial applications, you’d want something that’s all about the performance. Although the ARMA Foil Radiant Barrier does have industrial-grade features, the pricing is aggressive. For this reason, we are calling it the best residential roofing underlayment.
The Polyethylene fabric with deposited Aluminium coating does have slight light bleeding effects. But that’s a very minor issue. You may not even notice it’s there.
Other than that, there’s really no deal-breaking negatives of the ARMA Foil. It’s got a reflective aluminum coating on both sides. Also, durability and breathability are considerably good. All in all, it’s a complete package fit for residential applications. It’s also suited for industrial applications as well.
Roof Protector Underlayment Roll – Best Roof Underlayment for Metal Roof
When it comes to roof renovation, dealing with metal roofing is often a noticeable problem. And if you’re one of those users who are facing this problem, then you may want to consider this Roof Protector Underlayment.
When it comes to the overall features, then you’d want to consider its material, which is very robust to say the very least. It’s lightweight and very suitable for different varieties of roofing options. Other than its compatibility, it does have good weather resistance as well.
Due to such a robust combination of features, we are calling it the best roof underlayment for metal roof. Despite its negligible water leaking problems, I think it’s one of the very few options out there with such good value for the money.
Plastic String Reinforced Poly Sheeting – Best Value Roofing Underlayment
A budget product doesn’t necessarily imply that it’s cheap. When we are calling something a budget product, we’re implying that it gets all the basics right.
And when it comes to the best value roofing underlayment, then the Plastic String Reinforced Poly Sheeting gets checks all the boxes when it comes to the basics.
The clear multipurpose membrane is durable, handles water leakage like a champ. Also, competitive pricing is one of the noteworthy features that make it stand out as well. Overall, the usability and functionality are decent enough for an average consumer.
Overall, if you’re someone who lives in a fairly calm environment, we would recommend you give this a shot. You won’t be disappointed.
Roofing Underlayment Wind by MCM – Best Roof Underlayment for Tile Roofs
Tile Roofs are very common among users. Not only because they look good, but they’re also fairly priced nowadays. That’s why we saved the best roof underlayment for tile roofs for last.
A roofing underlayment usually has all the basic features you’d want in 2019. But the compatibility aspect is what separates it from all the other options in the market. And that’s what makes the best roof underlayment for an individual user.
And this underlayment has all the usability features you’ll want. For starters, the asphalt adhesive does a cracking job of keeping water leakage at bay, which is nice. Also, the non-slip surface offers top-notch safety, which is something that any user would be glad to have. Furthermore, the thickness distribution is also something to take into account.
Overall, we believe it is a very compelling package for both professionals and DIY users. Despite the weight, we believe it is an option anyone would be happy to use.
Buying Guide: Choosing the Right Roof Underlayment
So far, we’ve given you some options for the best roof underlayment. And now it’s time to take the next step, which is, of course, the decision making process.
First of all, there’s one thing that needs to be out of the way first. And that is the fact that you don’t need to be professional. You can get it all done if you’re willing to commit.
That’s the easy part.
The tough choices come as considerations. Although they may seem like simple things, they can certainly make a huge difference. So, without further ado, let’s get into it.
Is it compatible?
This is the very first question you need to ask yourself.
If the roof underlayment you’re using isn’t compatible with the use case you’re going for, then it’s possible that you may not get that top-tier level of convenience.
Although many brands are compatible with various different applications, it’s a good idea to check with the manufacturer before pulling the trigger.
Which material should you for?
That’s an interesting question. Let’s see some common use cases.
You see, when it comes to dealing with traditional shingle roofing, it’s a good idea to go with roofing felt, and especially something that is lightweight.
But with metal roofs, having an extra synthetic layer underneath can be a lifesaver. Metal roofs tend to trap a lot of excess heat, which is a problem when dealing with higher temperatures. This makes an already tasking workload eve more annoying.
So, you may want to pay attention to the material choice. This may help you make the most of your hard-earned cash.
How good is the weather condition?
The weather condition can play a huge role in buying the best roof underlayment. It will affect your working conditions directly.
There are plenty of options out there that are not that durable. As a matter of fact, they can’t even handle tough weather conditions for even a small amount of time. If that’s the case, then you may want to rethink about the product.
One remedy here can be brand reliability. Reliable brands are always looking to give you the most value for your money. And ultimately, that’s what matters the most in the long run.
Still, if you’re on a tight budget, then it may be a good decision to check for the weather resistance feature specifically. Checking reviews and having a chat with the respective online representative is a quick and easy option here.
Is it good against water leakage?
Water leakage is a major issue whenever you’re dealing with roof renovations. This is a very important feature to have for a piece of equipment you use for construction.
Almost all the roof underlayment products these days have waterproofing capabilities. But the thing you should be looking for is-whether it does a good job or not.
It’s actually one of the more important features that need special attention. You wouldn’t want to have water seeping through the roof of your home would you now?
Roof Underlayment FAQ
Now we’d like to share a few answers to some of the frequently asked questions regarding roof underlayment.
Question: Why would I even need roof underlayment?
Ans.: For those of you reading this review, you may want to pay attention for a moment here.
Usually, a roof underlayment is an extra protective layer to save you from water leakage and other small-scale hazards. This is more of an extra layer of protection before the shingles on your roof are installed.
Now you don’t really need a roof underlayment in general. But if you’re not cool with water seeping through the roof, then we think it is a very urgent consideration.
Question: Which underlayment should I choose-synthetic or felt?
Ans.: It’s a variable that does have some impact on your budget.
With felt underlayment, though it’s cheap, it doesn’t offer as robust safety features as the synthetic option. Now synthetic materials do offer a certain level of convenience, in some cases better than felt. But it is a bit on the expensive side. Overall, for better safety, you may want to go with a synthetic option, if you’re budget permits it of course.
Question: Should I do the roofing in the rainy season?
Ans.: The answer is a big resounding NO.
Let’s say you are ignoring our advice and going with your plan. Not only will the shingles not stick to the roof, but you will also have to deal with other safety hazards. This may increase the overall cost as well.
Question: How long will it take to reroof?
Ans.: It mostly depends on the size of your roof. Usually, the average time frame is 3 to 4 days for a complete tear-off. For underlayment application and new shingle installation, you may need a day or two.
You may also like:-
So, that had been the list of best roof underlayment reviews of 2019. By now, we expect you to pick up the right roof underlayment within your budget. Once done, make sure that you’ve installed it in the right manner. See you in next post!
- 1 Best Roof Underlayment 2019 – Comparison Table
- 2 ArmorLay 25 Synthetic Roof Underlayment – Top Rated Roof Underlayment
- 3 Tyvek Protec 120 – Best Roof Underlayment for Asphalt Shingles
- 4 ORGILL ROOFING FELT 30RF – Best Roofing Underlayment for Older Homes
- 5 Grace Ice & Water Shield – Best Waterproof Roofing Underlayment
- 6 Synthetic Roll – Best Synthetic Roof Underlayment
- 7 Firestone Rubberguard™ 60 Mil Epdm – Best Underlayment for EPDM Roofing
- 8 ARMA Foil, Radiant Barrier, High Strength – Best Residential Roofing Underlayment
- 9 Roof Protector Underlayment Roll – Best Roof Underlayment for Metal Roof
- 10 Plastic String Reinforced Poly Sheeting – Best Value Roofing Underlayment
- 11 Roofing Underlayment Wind by MCM – Best Roof Underlayment for Tile Roofs
- 12 Buying Guide: Choosing the Right Roof Underlayment